Logo

The Genesis of the Unfair High Price

დავით ბასიაშვილი.png
Davit Basiashvili

Doctor of Economics (PhD), Associate Professor at Technical University of Georgia

სლავა.png
Slava Fetelava

Doctor of Economics (PhD), Lawyer, Associate Professor at Grigol Robakidze University

Abstract

The work is related to one the form of abuse of dominance - unfair purchase or sale prices or other unlawful trading conditions - direct and indirect determination (fixing) of trading conditions or unfair price and the practical aspects of their detection and prevention. The paper presents where, what and how unfairly high prices can arise.

It examines how and to what extent the principle of double standards of justice can affect the behavior of economic agents and consumers. Accordingly, it is concluded that in a dynamic economy and industry, investments and innovations play a vital/special role in the economy and in reality. Unfortunately, it is still unclear what the appropriate competitive price indicator is and what the standard of consumer welfare is during competitive pricing. Such natural comparisons are the firm's past prices or other current prices compared to its competitors. In turn, this comparison provides a basis for fair judgment.The paper presents the role and importance of competition authorities in detecting and preventing unfairly high prices. Finally, it is concluded that the study of the facts of direct or indirect fixing of unfair purchase or sale prices or other unfair trading conditions by economic agents in a dominant position and therefore, determining the fact of operating at an unfairly high price is a very difficult process, both for competition authorities of countries with advanced international practice, and for novice competition institutions of countries like Georgia.

The complication all of this is evident, that an excessive price is not in itself unfair or wrong. Accordingly, the price needs to be assessed whether it is unfairly high, set by a dominant economic agent on the one hand excessive in itself and, on the other hand, excessive in relation to a competing company. In this regard, the paper highlights the decision of the Georgian Competition and Consumer Protection Agency (Auto Market Case) finalized on May 14, 2025, as a case law, the role and importance of the decision in the future, in the practical implementation of the country's competition policy.

Keywords: unfairly high price, first mover's competitive advantage, greater economy, unfair trading conditions, margin, cost, Court of Justice, European Commission.

References

  1. Fetelava S., Theory of competition and antimo­nopoly regulation in Georgia (In Georgian Language), Loi”, Tbilisi. 2007, https://dspace.nplg.gov.ge/ bitstream/1234/6152/1/Fetelava_Slava.pdf ;
  2. Basiashvili Davit, Fetelava Slava. Legal and Practical Aspects of Cartel Detection and Prevent, Journal "New Economist", DOI Suffix: 10.36962/NEC19022024-48, 2024, No. 2-3, pp. 48-56, (in Georgian Language);
  3. Explanatory dictionary of competition terms (compilers: Keti Zukakishvili, Keti Lafachi, Yueate Sovi­ene, Liana Japaridze), second edition, (In Georgian Lan­guage), Tbilisi, Georgia, 2023, UDC 330.342.141, K-731;
  4. https://medium.com/@Rokk3r.inc/6-successful-companies-that-were-not-the-first-movers-in-their-industries-187fee522d8c
  5. Nils Wahl, Exploitative high prices and European competition law – a personal reflection. The Pros and Cons of High Prices, Konkurrensverket Swedish Competition Authority p.51
  6. https://accountend.com/understanding-market-efficiency-theory-weak-semi-strong-and-strong-forms/#semi-strong-form-efficiency
  7. PRINCIPLES OF ECONOMICS, N Gregory Mankiw, Second edition, p 94
  8. Daniel Kahneman, Jack L. Knestch, Richard H. Thaler: “Fairness and The Assumptionof Economics”, The Journal of Business October 1986
  9. PRINCIPLES OF ECONOMICS, N Gregory Mankiw, Second edition, p 270
  10. Gregor Mankiw, Microeconomics, eighth edition, p 260-261
  11. https://ethicsunwrapped.utexas.edu/video/daraprim-price-hike
  12. https://www.findlaw.com/consumer/consumer-transactions/price-gouging-laws-by-state.html
  13. Pinar Akman and Luke Garrod, When Are Excessive Prices Unfair, 2010
  14. Miroslava Marinova, Unmasking excessive pricing: evolution of EU law on excessive pricing from United Brands to Aspen
  15. The Pros and Cons of High Prices Konkurrensverket Swedish Competition Authority Exploitative high prices and European competition law – a personal reflection By Nils Wah
  16. David S Evans and A Jorje Padilla “Excessive Price: Using Economics to Define Administrable Legal Rules” centre for Ecomomic Policy Resarch, Discussion Paper Series
  17. Miroslava Marinova, Unmasking excessive pricing: evolution of EU law on excessive pricing from United Brands to Aspen, p 330. To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/17441056.2023.228032
  18. Voir M. Martinez, “Some Views on Pricing and EC Competition Policy”, mimeo at p.6. Available online at http://ec.europa.eu/comm/competition/
  19. Damien Geradin, Abusive pricing in an IP licensing context: An EC competition law analysis, P. 14
  20. The Pros and Cons of High Prices Konkurrensverket Swedish Competition Authorit. P.18
  21. www.gcca.gov.ge (Case of LLC “Rustavi Auto Market” and LLC “Mikado Georgia”).
  22. John A. Shedd “Salt from My Attic” (1928), The Mosher Press, Portland, Maine, p. 20

The new Economist, No2, 2025, Vol. 20, Issue 2.

The New Economist 2, 2025
Published Date:

11/07/2025

Article Views: 17